Golf

The Players: PGA Tour stars ready for major test at TPC Sawgrass as 'fifth major' debate splits views within sport

👤
By Admin
Sports Journalist
The Players: PGA Tour stars ready for major test at TPC Sawgrass as 'fifth major' debate splits views within sport

The Players may not hold the official major status many debate it could, but the PGA Tour’s Flagship Event is expected this week to provide – once again – one of the highlights in the golfing calendar.

Rory McIlroy returns as defending champion after his play-off victory over JJ Spaun, following on from Scottie Scheffler's back-to-back wins the previous two years, leaving both with the chance to join Jack Nicklaus as the only three-time champion in the event's history.

FedExCup champion Tommy Fleetwood is among a strong contingent looking to end the long wait for a first English winner of The Players, while two-time major champion Collin Morikawa aims to follow early-season PGA Tour success with another title.

The tournament has regularly been labelled as an unofficial 'fifth major' because of its strength of field, iconic host venue and huge prize money on offer at TPC Sawgrass, with that discussion reignited by the PGA Tour's promotional video ahead of this year's contest.

"March is going to be major," was the tagline used by the PGA Tour, fuelling the fresh conversation about whether it could be classified alongside The Masters, PGA Championship, US Open and The Open amongst men's golf's traditional majors.

"I think The Players is one of the best golf tournaments in the world," McIlroy said last month ahead of his title defence, live from Thursday on Your Site Golf. "I don't think anyone disputes that or argues that.

"I think from a player perspective it's amazing. I think from an on-site fan experience it's amazing. It's an amazing golf course, location, venue. But I'm a traditionalist, I'm a historian of the game and we have four major championships."

The continued ineligibility of LIV Golf League players has made its major billing a harder argument to make, but McIlroy - who completed the career Grand Slam last April - believes The Players holds its own clear place in the sport.

"It's The Players - it doesn't need to be anything else," McIlroy added. "I would say it's got more of an identity than the PGA Championship does at the minute. So like from an identity standpoint, I think The Players has got it nailed.

"The Players is an amazing tournament in its own right and I don't think it being classified a major or not a major makes it any more or any less. I'm still very proud to have won that tournament twice as I'm sure all the other champions are. It stands on its own without the label, I guess."

Phil Mickelson shut down the idea of The Players being recognised as a major, saying last month 'I've won it. It's not.', although former FedExCup champion Billy Horschel believes is strong enough to be given improved status.

"I've said it for a while - I think it is a fifth major," Horschel told Your Site at the Arnold Palmer Invitational. "Whether it gets voted a fifth major, it doesn't bother me at all.

"If between the majors and The Players, if all I won was a Players Championship, I would consider it a major because that's what I think of the event. I think when you look at the history of the event, the way it's promoted, the way the support is in the Northeast Florida community, I think it deserves to be a major.

"I am biased - I live there. I have a great relationship with a lot of people in the PGA Tour, not just the top execs. There's a lot of people that work there that do so much for the PGA Tour that don't get the recognition. I would like to see it a major, but I'm not going to lose sleep over it."

Bryson DeChambeau, Jon Rahm, Patrick Reed, Tyrrell Hatton and 2022 champion Cameron Smith are among the others unable to feature since joining the LIV Golf League, although Golf Channel analyst Brandel Chamblee insists The Players remains the strongest field in golf.

"I would argue that The Players does exactly what a major championship is supposed to do," Chamblee told the Your Site Golf podcast. "All of the other major championships I would say no longer, especially now that the game is fractured, assemble the best fields.

"Some fields are accumulated with exemptions and past winners, so their exemptions are somewhat political. You look at the US Open and it's open. You look at The Open, it's open.

"It provides wonderful stories and themes and underdog stories but, from a meritocratic standpoint, they are not the best players over the course of a year. What the Players does is assemble year in and year out the best, deepest, and most meritocratic elite field in all of golf.

"History should never be inherited. It is accumulated by successful competitive fields over time. The Players has been around 50 years and been at TPC Sawgrass since 1982. In that period of time, it has consistently delivered the best field in all of major championship golf."

This week's venue continues to provide a unique test to players, with the famous 'island' par-three 17th among the standout features of a course that doesn't suit a particular style of player.

"The golf course can just challenge you in a variety of ways, and I think that's what makes it a great test," Scheffler said ahead of last year's title defence, where he ended tied-20th. "It's not a horses-for-courses-type place, it's just the guys that are playing the best are going to be on the leaderboard on Sunday."

Scheffler remains the only player to successfully defend his title at The Players, with the world No 1 one of just eight players to have won the tournament on multiple occasions.

"I would argue, based upon the nature of the golf course and the fact that only one time has it ever been successfully defended, it is also the hardest tournament to win in all of golf," Chamblee explained. "Unlike every other major championship, it doesn't allow one style of play to win.

"It's not based upon power. It's not based about on precision. It does not need one week of heavy rough or one week of a type of setup. People love to criticise TPC Sawgrass, but it is amongst the very best golf courses in the world to play a major championship."

The last two winners of The Players have gone on to win The Masters a month later, with McIlroy crediting his Sawgrass success last year as a 'springboard of self-belief' towards ending his 11-year wait for a fifth major title.

Whoever PGA Tour chief executive Brian Rolapp is presenting the trophy to on Sunday will not have won a major title, but they will have earned major recognition - and potentially set up a big year ahead - for claiming one of golf's most prestigious prizes.

Watch The Players throughout the week live on Your Site. Live coverage of the opening round begins on Thursday from 11.30am on Your Site Golf. or .

Share this article